neither looks great, but neither looks awful...
Both look like popcorn films but I'd watch them. I was unsure how I'd go with Mel Gibspon back IN a film, but I think I could handle it. There's a kind of irony around his last statement in the trailer . . .
I think Dear John will be decent. Tatum looks better than I thought he'd be (which I am glad about), but I wasn't really feeling any connection between him and Seyfried. I think the more compelling aspect of that story might be between Tatum and Jenkins...The Edge of Darkness looks good...nothing spectacular, but does look like a good popcorn movie I'd see.