A.O. Scott
1) Where the Wild Things Are
2) The Hurt Locker/In the Loop
3) Summer Hours/Of Time and the City
4) Up in the Air/Funny People
5) Bright Star/Medicine for Melancholy
6) Precious/Coraline
7) Avatar/District 9
8 A Serious Man/Anvil: The Story of Anvil
9) Goodbye, Solo/Sugar
10)Gomorrah/The Baader Meinhof Complex
Manohla Dargis (unranked, Top 13):
-Gomorrah
-Tulpan
-Summer Hours
-The Hurt Locker
-The Beaches of Agnes
-Public Enemies
-Beeswax
-Ponyo
-The Informant!
-Where the Wild Things Are
-Fantastic Mr. Fox
-The Sun
-Avatar
Stephen Holden:
1) Up in the Air
2) The White Ribbon
3) Still Walking
4) The Messenger
5) 35 Shots of Rum
6) The Hurt Locker
7) The Headless Woman
8 An Education
9) Summer Hours
10) Disgrace
-I gotta say, A.O. Scott loving Funny People as much as I do makes me smile...thoughts?
I never really got the whole "my top 10 is really a top 13" thing, but hey, far from me to judge...
ReplyDeleteAre these the first lists to completely ignore "Up?"
ReplyDeletePerhaps, though I must confess, Up is not currently in my top 10 either (currently resides at number 16)...
ReplyDeleteIn the Loop! (I'm back from the dead, sorry guys) . . .
ReplyDelete